Identity theft isn't just about stolen credit card numbers. It often begins with something much simpler: a document.
From a misplaced Social Security card to an emailed tax return, even a single exposed file can provide everything a thief needs to open accounts, claim refunds, or impersonate you or someone you love.
Understanding which documents are most vulnerable can help you and your family take meaningful steps to prevent identity theft — especially if you’re already organizing your records or storing them digitally.
The Hidden Risks in Everyday Documents
Q: Which personal documents are most valuable to identity thieves?
A: Social Security numbers are the crown jewel for identity thieves. The Federal Trade Commission reports that 74% of identity theft cases involve a stolen Social Security number — often at the center of synthetic identity theft and tax refund fraud.
In 2023 alone, the FTC received over 1.1 million fraud reports involving misuse of personal data, with Social Security numbers leading the list.
Q: What financial records are commonly targeted?
A: Bank statements, credit card bills, loan documents, and even voided checks are frequent targets. These often contain names, addresses, account numbers, and other details that can be used to open fraudulent accounts or take over existing ones.
In the 2022 Identity Fraud Study by Javelin Strategy & Research, 46% of U.S. victims reported unauthorized activity on their credit card accounts.
Q: Are government-issued IDs a high risk if lost or copied?
A: Yes. Lost or stolen driver’s licenses, passports, and green cards can be used to verify false identities, commit loan fraud, or bypass Know Your Customer regulations.
The Identity Theft Resource Center’s 2023 report found that nearly one in five identity theft victims said their fraud began after a stolen document.
How to Keep Your Information Safe
That’s why secure digital storage matters. Tools like Trustworthy allow families to safely store and share important documents with bank-level encryption and tokenization, and permission controls. Trustworthy's Family Operating System® is a better alternative to relying on email, screenshots, or physical file folders.
Q: What about medical records — are they a target too?
A: Absolutely. Medical identity theft is one of the fastest-growing forms of fraud.
According to the Ponemon Institute and Experian, 27% of identity theft victims were affected by medical ID fraud in 2022. Stolen insurance cards, health records, or explanation-of-benefits documents can be used to receive medical care, prescriptions, or file false insurance claims — sometimes altering your health history in the process.
Q: Do identity thieves go after documents belonging to children?
A: Yes — and they’re harder to detect. Children’s identities are rarely monitored, making them prime targets for years-long fraud.
Birth certificates, Social Security numbers, and school enrollment forms should be stored and shared with care. Many families don’t discover child identity theft until a first job, college application, or loan denial brings it to light.
Q: Are paper documents safer than digital ones?
A: Not necessarily. Paper documents are vulnerable to loss, theft, damage, and unauthorized access.
On the other hand, digital documents can be extremely secure — if stored using encrypted systems with access control and monitoring. The FTC recommends shredding sensitive paper records and encrypting digital ones as best practices.
Q: What’s the best way to store and protect high-risk documents?
A: A secure digital vault like Trustworthy is your best defense. It allows you to store essential family documents in one protected location, accessible only to you and those you trust.
The Bottom Line
Identity thieves don’t need much to cause lasting damage — just one exposed document can open the door to fraud. The good news is that when you know what they’re looking for, you can take proactive steps to keep those files secure.
Whether you’re safeguarding your own information or protecting your family’s most sensitive records, secure storage and thoughtful sharing are the most effective defenses.
And with Trustworthy, it’s easier than ever to keep your documents private, organized, and fully protected — without relying on memory, risky habits, or scattered files. Try Trustworthy for free, for as long as you like.
We’d love to hear from you! Feel free to email us with any questions, comments, or suggestions for future article topics.
Trustworthy is an online service providing legal forms and information. We are not a law firm and do not provide legal advice.
